Thrifting for a Cause: 8 Vintage Home Decor Finds from Maine’s Another Chance Thrift Shoppe

Inside Another Chance Thrift Shoppe in Southern Maine: A Hidden Gem for Vintage Home Decor

If you ever find yourself thrifting in Southern Maine, don’t miss Another Chance Animal Rescue in North Berwick, a hidden gem that supports Another Chance Animal Rescue (ACAR), a local no-kill foster home caring for cats and kittens year-round, seven days a week by appointment.

I originally stumbled upon this charming spot while detouring from a nearby community yard sale that turned out to be a bit of a bust. But just around the corner? Pure vintage magic. Nestled next to a hardware store in what was once an old pharmacy, this little Maine thrift shop is now filled with beautiful vintage home decor, unique furniture, fashion finds, and warm-hearted purpose. And yes, it still has true thrift store prices that make the treasure hunt even more rewarding.

Let’s take a peek inside…

Decorating a Vintage Home with Thrifted Finds

Decorating a vintage home is all about curating unique, meaningful pieces that tell a story, and there’s no better place to start than a cozy thrift shop. From rare vintage dinnerware to a weathered shoe shine box by the entryway, every find brings with it a layer of charm and character.

By styling your space with thrifted vintage home decor, you can create a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels both timeless and personal. Whether it’s a creative table setting using Johnson Brothers china, or a whimsical bird feeder made from a teacup, each piece adds to the story your home tells.

That’s exactly the magic I discovered during my visit to Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, and I’m excited to show you how I brought that magic home.

Vintage Home Decor Thrifted Finds from Another Chance Thrift Shoppe

Once I picked my jaw up off the floor after walking into Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, I couldn’t wait to start thrifting. This charming Southern Maine thrift store is not only beautifully curated, but every purchase supports a no-kill cat rescue, making every treasure feel even more special.

From blue and white dinnerware to rare Johnson Brothers china and a vintage shoe valet box, I found so many unique pieces that now bring warmth, character, and history into our vintage home. Here’s a closer look at my favorite finds, and how I styled each one to reflect the cozy, collected look I love.

Blue and White Bowl with Vintage Teacups

What I Found:
One of my favorite finds from Another Chance Thrift Shoppe was a large vintage blue and white bowl, beautifully styled in-store and filled with an assortment of delicate blue and white teacups, all for just five dollars. The layered effect was stunning and completely drew me in. I’ve always loved collecting blue and white vintage dinnerware, and this display was the perfect example of how simple pieces can be arranged creatively for major impact.

How I Styled It:
Back at our vintage home in Maine, I recreated a similar display in the kitchen. I nested the teacups inside the bowl just as I found them in the shop, playful, curated, and full of charm. This piece now sits on our kitchen counter as a conversation starter, but it could just as easily work on a living room coffee table, bookshelf, or sunroom sideboard. It’s a flexible and eye-catching way to showcase your blue and white vintage decor while telling a story with your collection.

Blue and White Porcelain Nesting Heart Bowls

What I found:
I couldn’t resist this charming set of blue and white porcelain nesting heart bowls at Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, and for only four dollars, they were an absolute steal. The soft blue floral patterns and sweet heart-shaped design make them perfect for adding a playful, romantic touch to any vintage home decor setting. These petite bowls are a collector’s dream and a creative twist on classic blue and white ceramics.

How I styled it:
I styled the nesting hearts on the coffee table in our coastal Maine living room, pairing them with a vintage white McCoy vase overflowing with white hydrangeas from the garden. The entire vignette celebrates the lush hydrangea blooms of the season and brings together vintage charm with a fresh summer feel. These bowls add just the right touch of detail and nostalgia to the space, and they’re so versatile for styling year-round.

Johnson Brothers Old English Chintz Dinnerware

What I found:
Tucked a few shelves down from the blue and white dinnerware on the original pharmacy shelving at Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, I spotted something truly special, a four-place set of vintage Johnson Brothers Old English Chintz dinnerware. Dating back to the 1930s and 1940s, this rare pattern is nearly antique and remarkably hard to find today. While the more common Rose Chintz and Autumn Delight patterns are lovely, this Old English version has a unique charm all its own. And the price? Just $20 for the full set. A true vintage treasure.

How I styled it:
I’m looking forward to using this dinnerware set to create cozy, seasonal table settings on our porch in Vermont this fall. With its vintage country cottage style and soft floral chintz pattern, it’s ideal for layering into a warm autumn tablescape. You can see how I’ve styled similar Johnson Brothers sets in my fall table decorating posts, including this Johnson Brothers Autumn Delight tablescape and my guide to creating a stunning fall tablescape you’ll love. It’s the kind of find that inspires a whole season of decorating.

See this vintage Chintz fall tablescape styled today in this How to Create a Stunning Fall Tablescape You’ll Love post.

Esquire Shoe Valet Box

What I found:
How about an old wooden shoeshine box made by Esquire for just six dollars? This vintage Esquire Shoe Valet came fully stocked with original shoeshine brushes, polishes, and cloths, a complete time capsule from the mid-20th century. Designed with a hinged lid and raised footrest on top, these classic wooden valets were once everyday staples for keeping shoes polished to perfection. The Esquire brand, known for its high-quality shoe care products, adds authenticity and value to this nostalgic piece, making it a standout item for collectors and vintage home decor lovers alike.

How I styled it:
While it may have been designed for practicality, this charming shoeshine box now serves as a warm and welcoming accent in our vintage home’s entryway. I’ve placed it between our dining room and front hall, where its rich wood tone and worn patina blend beautifully with other antique touches in the space. These vintage shoe valets are incredibly versatile, perfect for styling in a bathroom, mudroom, or bedroom as a storage piece with personality. Whether used decoratively or functionally, they bring timeless craftsmanship and a story into the home.

Vintage Newspapers with Historical Storm Headlines

What I found:
While I’ve never been one to collect old newspapers, this stack of vintage editions immediately caught my eye. Each one featured dramatic headlines documenting major New England storms, an irresistible find for someone like me who loves a good snowstorm. For just a dollar each, I couldn’t pass them up. These kinds of historical newspapers are not only nostalgic, but they also capture moments in time that are rich with storytelling potential and regional charm.

How I styled it:
I brought home a few of my favorites and styled them at our vintage desk in the dining room. They’ve become instant conversation pieces, layered with books and other collected accents. Vintage newspapers like these can also be framed as wall art, tucked into magazine baskets, or styled casually on coffee tables and side tables for a lived-in, collected look. Whether you’re into historical headlines, regional weather history, or simply want to add authentic vintage character to a room, these papers are an affordable and meaningful way to do it.

Vintage Home Teacup Bird Feeder

What I found:
I’ve always loved the charm of vintage teacup bird feeders, and this one was too sweet to pass up. For just six dollars, I brought home a red and white teacup and saucer set from Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, ready-made and ready to hang. These vintage-style bird feeders are not only adorable but also incredibly easy to make. All you need is a teacup, a saucer, and a little hot glue to attach them together, then simply hang it outside and fill the saucer with birdseed for your feathered friends to enjoy.

How I styled it:
This teacup bird feeder now hangs just outside our coastal Maine home, adding a touch of vintage whimsy to our outdoor decor. It blends beautifully with the garden and makes for a fun conversation piece when guests visit. Whether you find one ready-made or DIY your own with thrifted china, teacup bird feeders are a delightful way to repurpose vintage dishware and add character to your backyard or porch.

Bonus Vintage Finds: Gifts for a Friend in Maine

What I found:
One of my favorite parts of thrift shopping is picking up thoughtful treasures for friends, and this visit to Another Chance Thrift Shoppe in North Berwick, Maine, didn’t disappoint. For my friend Molly of the blog Molly in Maine, I found two perfect pieces: a heavy-duty outdoor garden statue of a Brittany Spaniel, just like her beloved dogs Maddie and Cisco, and a charming blue and white Cornish Ware pitcher to add to her growing collection. At just six dollars, the dog statue was an absolute steal, and the pitcher will be right at home in her vintage hutch filled with striped Cornish Ware pieces. These kinds of finds make thrift store shopping in Maine all the more special.

If you find yourself thrift shopping in North Berwick, Maine, don’t miss a visit to Another Chance Thrift Shoppe, a charming, creatively curated store that supports a heartfelt cause. Take a closer look inside:

Looking for more places to visit in Maine filled with vintage charm, coastal inspiration, and unforgettable local shops? Here are a few of my favorite stops, from antique stores to hidden gems you won’t want to miss:

Wrapping Up My Vintage Finds from Another Chance Thrift Shoppe

Every piece I discovered at Another Chance Thrift Shoppe in North Berwick, Maine brought with it a little history, a lot of charm, and the joy of supporting a thrift store with purpose. From the blue and white vintage dinnerware to the rare Johnson Brothers Chintz and the nostalgic Esquire shoeshine box, each find added something special to our vintage home decor, and even a few gifts for friends along the way.

If you’re planning a day of thrift shopping in Southern Maine, this cozy, cat-loving shop is a must-stop destination. It’s proof that small-town thrift stores can offer big-time inspiration.

Have you ever found something unexpected that completely transformed a space in your home? I’d love to hear about your favorite thrift store finds in the comments below, or tag me on Instagram so I can see how you style your vintage treasures too!

And don’t forget to pin this post for your next Maine vintage shopping adventure.

Pin forLater!

Shop This Post

This post may contain affiliate links, which won’t change your price but will share some commission.