Sherwin-Williams Stardew Paint Color, A Blue That Transformed Our Open Floor Plan

Looking for the perfect soft blue-gray paint color? Let me show you how Sherwin-Williams Stardew paint color transformed our open floor plan into a cozy, layered space filled with vintage charm. From painted walls and trim to a standout kitchen island, this calming blue brings depth, warmth, and timeless character to our Vermont home, all styled with collected vintage details and lived-in ease.

What You’ll Learn in This Post

Curious about using Sherwin-Williams Stardew paint color in your home? In this post, you’ll learn:

• How Sherwin-Williams Stardew compares to similar blue-gray paint colors if you’re considering alternatives.
• Why Stardew works so well as a soft blue-gray paint color in cozy, cottage-style, and vintage-inspired spaces.
• How Stardew looks in natural light and what undertones to expect/.
• The best coordinating paint colors, trim ideas, and accent pairings for a cohesive look.
• How I used Sherwin-Williams Stardew throughout our Vermont home to create a calm, timeless feel.

Planning your own interior makeover? Don’t miss the free Paint Planning Checklist below!

Meet Sherwin-Williams Stardew: The Blue-Gray Paint Color Everyone’s Loving

Sherwin-Williams Stardew is one of those blue-gray paint colors that feels both timeless and current all at once. Soft and slightly muted with a gentle hint of green, it has enough depth to feel interesting while still working beautifully throughout an entire home. We chose Sherwin-Williams Stardew for our open floor plan to create a calm, cohesive look that flows effortlessly from room to room.

Whether you’re painting living room walls, kitchen cabinets, or a cozy bedroom, Sherwin-Williams Stardew paint color brings an airy, relaxed feel without tipping too bold or too cool. It pairs especially well with crisp white trim like Chantilly Lace, warm natural wood tones, and layered vintage decor, creating a space that feels settled, welcoming, and comfortably pulled together.

Prepping for Paint: Our Sherwin-Williams Stardew Interior Makeover

Recently, we cleared out nearly every corner of our home to prepare for a full interior repaint, and it was absolutely worth it. This project marked the beginning of our Sherwin-Williams Stardew paint color makeover, transforming the entire space with a calm, cohesive palette that feels fresh yet timeless.

We chose Sherwin-Williams Stardew for the walls and Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace for the trim to create a soft, airy feel throughout the open floor plan. Our local painter spent over a week carefully prepping surfaces before spraying both the walls and trim, ensuring a smooth, professional finish.

The result was a clean, brightened space that feels lighter and more pulled together, allowing the vintage details and collected decor to truly shine.

Meet Jay, Our Local Painter

Before painting began, we gathered a few local estimates and were fortunate to work with Jay of Mud Patch and Paint, LLC. He was not only affordable and experienced, but ready to take on a full interior repaint using a soft blue-gray paint color. Our goal was to refresh the open floor plan with Sherwin-Williams Stardew on the walls, paired with bright white ceilings and trim for a clean, classic finish.

Jay estimated the project would take about three weeks, so we headed to our Maine home while the work was underway. The scope included nearly the entire house, including the kitchen, living room, dining room, and sitting room in the open layout, along with two guest bedrooms for trim and ceilings, one bathroom, and three hallways.

We saved the bedrooms for a later phase with wallpaper, which I share more about in this post: Bedroom Wallpaper Ideas for Beautiful Home Decor.

Before spraying began, Jay carefully protected all of our wood floors and focused heavily on prep, which made all the difference in the final result. Watching the transformation unfold reinforced just how important thoughtful preparation and a clear paint plan really are.

Clearing the Walls: A Refreshing First Step

Before painting began, we prepped our home by clearing every shelf, wall, and surface. That included removing a few decorative shelves over windows and doorways, pieces I had lived with for years but never truly loved.

Once they were gone, the kitchen immediately felt more open and less cluttered. It was one of those small changes that made a big impact and honestly made me wish I’d done it sooner. If you’re planning to repaint, taking the time to remove anything that no longer feels right is a simple but powerful way to refresh your space before the first coat of paint ever goes on.

Here’s a handy checklist of what to consider before the paint goes up, from sample testing to clearing wall decor and choosing the right finish. Feel free to pin or save it for later!

Why I Chose Sherwin-Williams Stardew for Our Open Floor Plan

Choosing a paint color for a full home interior is no small decision, especially in an open floor plan where every room flows together and natural light shifts throughout the day. I knew I wanted a soft blue-gray paint color that felt calm, light, and fresh, a look I had been imagining for years.

In the store, Sherwin-Williams Stardew appeared slightly deeper with a subtle green undertone. But once I painted sample boards and tested it at home, the color completely transformed. With abundant natural light, French doors, and minimal wall breaks, Stardew softened into a welcoming blue-gray that felt airy and relaxed.

In our space, it did not read green at all. Instead, it struck that just-right balance between fresh and grounded, pairing beautifully with crisp white trim and enhancing the clean, cozy feel we wanted throughout the home. After testing more than a dozen blue paint colors, I ultimately chose Sherwin- Williams Stardew for its versatility, warmth, and timeless appeal.

Sherwin-Williams Stardew Kitchen Island

One of my favorite decisions was painting our kitchen island in Sherwin-Williams Stardew, too. It added a subtle pop of color that helped visually break up the open concept without overpowering it, such a simple but high-impact touch.

Every home is different, so what looks good in one house may not look the same in yours. Testing the colors out on your own walls is key.

Coordinating Colors That Work Beautifully with Sherwin-Williams Stardew

Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace: A Bright White That Pairs Perfectly with Stardew

Once we chose Sherwin-Williams Stardew as our main wall color, the next step was selecting a white trim that would complement it without introducing yellow or creamy undertones. We landed on Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace, a crisp, bright white that stays clean and fresh alongside cooler paint colors like Stardew.

Before this update, our trim was painted in Sherwin-Williams Alabaster, which has a warmer, creamier feel. While Alabaster is a beautiful color in the right setting, it felt a bit too warm next to Stardew’s soft blue-gray tones. Chantilly Lace provided the contrast we were looking for and helped sharpen the overall look of the space. Learn more in my Navajo White Sherwin-Williams Review & Real Home Photos post.

The result is a clean, airy combination that lets Sherwin-Williams Stardew shine while keeping the trim bright and timeless. It was one of those choices that made the entire color palette feel finished and intentional, and yes, my husband ended up loving it just as much as the blue.

Spray Painting vs. Brushing: What Worked Best for Our Interior Makeover

Spray Painting the Walls with Sherwin-Williams Stardew Blue

For this project, we chose to have our interior professionally spray-painted rather than using traditional rollers or brushes, and it was absolutely the right choice for our home. With an open floor plan, spray painting delivers a smoother, more uniform finish, especially around trim, built-ins, and large wall surfaces.

Spray Painting the Ceilings: Full Coverage in Action

While spray painting requires more extensive preparation, including covering floors, taping windows, and carefully masking every surface, the application itself moves quickly and produces a consistent, professional result. The finish feels clean and seamless, which was exactly the look we wanted with Sherwin-Williams Stardew throughout the space.

Painting the Kitchen Island in Sherwin-Williams Stardew Blue

Aside from a few minor brush touch-ups, the entire interior was completed using a sprayer. I’m sharing a few behind-the-scenes videos of the process, which really show how much of a difference this method makes when you’re repainting an entire home.

The full spray application of Sherwin-Williams Stardew took about one day, followed by two additional days of touch-ups and cleanup to make sure every surface looked just right.

A big thank-you to our painter, Jay Ouellette of Mud Patch and Paint LLC, for his careful work and for documenting the process with photos and videos while we stayed mostly out of the way at our Maine home. Seeing the transformation come together so seamlessly made the entire project feel even more rewarding.

Sherwin-Williams Stardew: The Final Results in Our Home

These are the first unfiltered photos our painter sent over right after the job was complete. They show how Sherwin-Williams Stardew paint color subtly shifts depending on light, time of day, and room placement. In person, the color reads even softer and brighter than it does in photos, but sharing these images helps give a realistic sense of how Stardew behaves across natural light, shadows, and open spaces.

Our painter described Stardew as a “dependent color,” and that couldn’t be more accurate. Paired with crisp Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace trim, the cooler blue tones in the Stardew walls really come through, creating a fresh, airy feel throughout the home. During the day, the color feels light and breezy, while in the evening it settles into a warmer, more grounded blue-gray. Together, Stardew and Chantilly Lace have become one of my favorite paint combinations we’ve ever used.

What I Wish I Knew About the Post-Paint Cleanup

One thing I didn’t fully anticipate was just how much dust comes with a full interior spray-paint project. Between sanding, prepping, and painting nearly the entire home, a fine layer of dust settled on interior windows, floors, and surfaces throughout the house.

While the results were absolutely worth it, the cleanup was more involved than expected. If I were doing this project again, I’d plan ahead and schedule a professional post-renovation cleaning before moving back in. They have the right tools to handle fine dust efficiently and would have made the transition back into the space much easier. If you’re working with a painter, it’s also worth asking whether cleanup services can be included or coordinated ahead of time.

The Final Layer: Living with Sherwin-Williams Stardew Paint Color

Once the furniture was moved back in and the rooms were styled, Sherwin-Williams Stardew truly came to life. This is the stage where paint color stops feeling like a project choice and starts feeling like part of how a home lives and breathes. Even in spaces where the walls aren’t fully visible, the color creates a calm backdrop that connects each room and allows vintage pieces, wood tones, and natural light to shine.

Living Room Styling with Sherwin-Williams Stardew

In our living room, Stardew works more quietly behind the scenes. With French doors, built-in bookcases, and architectural details taking center stage, the paint color frames the built-ins painted in Chantilly Lace white rather than competing with it. The soft blue-gray tone adds depth around the doors and trim, helping the room feel grounded and cohesive without overpowering the furnishings.

This is where Stardew really shows its strength in an open floor plan. It supports the room’s character and collected decor while allowing books, artwork, and vintage pieces to stand out naturally.

Dining Room Styling with Sherwin Williams Stardew

The dining room is where Sherwin Williams Stardew becomes more visible and impactful. The color wraps the space in a calm, welcoming tone that works beautifully with natural wood furniture and layered table settings. It creates an easy transition between the living areas while still giving the dining room its own sense of place.

Styled with vintage pieces and warm textures, the blue-gray walls feel timeless rather than trendy, making the space just as comfortable for everyday meals as it is for gatherings.

Our Kitchen in Sherwin Williams Stardew

In the kitchen, Sherwin Williams Stardew adds just the right amount of color without overwhelming the space. Paired with bright Chantilly Lace trim and cabinetry details, the blue-gray walls feel fresh and clean while still warm and inviting.

The color shifts throughout the day here, appearing lighter and airier in the morning and slightly deeper by evening. It’s a subtle change, but one that makes the kitchen feel lived-in and layered rather than static.

Entryway and First Impressions with Sherwin Williams Stardew

Our entryway ties everything together. As the first space you see when walking in, Stardew sets the tone for the rest of the home. It immediately feels calm and welcoming, offering a soft transition into the open floor plan beyond.

Sherwin Williams Stardew Paint Color, A Soft Blue-Gray for a Cozy Open Floor Plan

Living with Sherwin Williams Stardew paint color has only confirmed that it was the right choice for our open floor plan. It’s the kind of blue-gray that adapts beautifully to light, works quietly in the background, and supports a collected, lived-in home rather than overpowering it. From bright daytime moments to cozy evenings, the color continues to feel calm, timeless, and easy to live with.

If you’re considering Stardew for your own home, especially in a space where rooms flow together, this paint color offers flexibility, warmth, and long-term appeal. It’s proof that the right paint choice doesn’t just change how a home looks, it changes how it feels.

If you’re exploring more paint color ideas or thinking about layering wallpaper into your home, I’ve shared several other real-life projects using soft neutrals, blues, and vintage-inspired patterns. From full-room paint makeovers to wallpapered bedrooms and accent spaces, these posts show how color and pattern can work together to create a home that feels thoughtful and personal.

Pin forLater!